3 porch ideas for Ashley’s adorable midcentury house

Design Dilemma Ashley's front porch polesReader Ashley has an outdoor Retro Design Dilemma — our first exterior challenge — how exciting! Ashley’s house looks pretty darn cute already, but there is something perplexing about her front porch. Read on to find out more about Ashley’s dilemma and three possible solutions to her porch problem…

3 porch ideas for Ashley's adorable midcentury houseAshley writes:

I’m trying to get more information on round metal porch posts. My house was built in 1949. The previous owners did something weird with the porch, but I can’t completely figure out what they did. The metal posts seem original to me. As you can see from the pictures, they spray painted the entire house a taupe/beige color, and didn’t bother to cover the posts, which look to be originally black. It seems odd to me that there are no railings or anything. I’ve seen the article on the pretty ornamental porch railings and posts, but I’ve never seen any pictures of just plain round black posts with no railings before. What do I do with them? Just repaint them black? Add railings? I can’t find any pictures on the internet of any old houses with plain black posts like this. I have NO idea what to do with the front of my house! PLEASE help me!

round_metal_porch_support_polesMy first thought regarding these round metal poles on Ashley’s porch — they surely couldn’t be original. I doubt porches in 1949 were typically held up by the kind of round, metal poles that we most commonly see used to reinforce support beams in basements. If they are indeed original, I’ve never seen a midcentury house with porch posts like this before. I’m thinking that somewhere along the line, the original posts (and possibly even railings) rotted or gave out causing the need for some structural support — and the previous owners went with this very basic, effective — but aesthetically blah — solution. Regardless of their origins, I can see why Ashley wants our help.

Pam was quick to remind me of a post she wrote a while back about midcentury homes with a lack of curb appeal, which had a great illustration from a vintage Dutch Boy flyer depicting a cute little house with an even cuter little porch. I instantly knew this type of porch railing would look great on Ashley’s house. Using the power of Photoshop, Ashley’s porch was instantly transformed.

retro_porch_makeover_1But what happened to the poles? In my opinion, you could do one of two things:

  1. Build boxes around the poles — wrapping them in wood — to make them into square wooden porch posts
  2. Replace the current metal poles with solid wooden porch posts (after consulting with a pro of course!)

Once the poles are replaced/wrapped, you could then attach any sort of railing you desired. In the solution above, I added a railing similar to the retro Dutch Boy ad from Pam’s midcentury curb appeal post. I’d make the posts and railings white, to blend with the soffit and trim and then add an accent color (I chose an aqua) to the front door, garage door and newly added shutters. The shutters have the same raised panel design as Ashley’s current front door and help to add interest as well as give a more finished look to the front of the house.

To spruce up the yard, tall shrubs were placed at the edges of the house — which nicely frame the porch and garden space.  Planting shorter shrubs in between helps to fill in the gaps. These shorter shrubs were chosen for their coloration — one being a blueish evergreen shrub — to echo the aqua trim color — and the others are bright pink knock out rose bushes to dial up the color making the overall view of Ashley’s house a little less neutral. A few more clumps of pink flowers out by the pole light help to hide its cement base and repeat the pink — just like an indoor room design, repeating colors helps to make the exterior of a house feel more cohesive and finished. I’m not sure exactly what part of the country Ashley lives in, so I’d advise checking with a local garden center to help suggest which species of plants and shrubs would work best in her yard.

retro_porch_makeover_2For the second solution, I’d use the same method of either wrapping or replacing the metal porch posts mentioned above. Once that is done, installing some easy horizontal railings would give Ashley’s house more of a ranch vibe, which could also be repeated on the shutters. Instead of painting the poles and trim bright white, using a beige several shades lighter than the siding would create a less stark affect —  painting the other white trim beige to match would complete the look. Painting the garage door and front window trim would add some color and a new door (or door kit) from Crestview doors, painted in a terra cotta would really liven up the entry. Once again, I would plant tall shrubs to act as a frame around the edges of the house and fill in with shorter shrubs. A reddish hued shrub (like a crimson barberry) would blend nicely with the terra cotta front door.

retro_porch_makeover_3For the third solution — after wrapping or replacing the porch poles — I would install a classic white vertical railing. The pizazz in this design comes from the retro diamond patterns on the shutters and the front door in addition to a Crestview door kit, or a new door and a fun shade of purple on the shutters, front door and garage door. Tall shrubs once again frame the space and add height, but this time a secondary focal point — a large landscape rock — is placed near the curve of Ashley’s sidewalk. Planting purple flowers (like petunias or pansies) around the rock help distribute the purple trim color out into the yard. An arrangement of yellow rose bushes, forsythia and marigolds complement the purple trim (purple and yellow are complementary colors) and finish the look of this solution.

Pam interjects here: Ashley, I presume you had a house inspection and were told your front porch is effectively supported. If not — consult with a properly licensed professional to ensure it is. Also, check with your local building inspector to ensure that any work you are planning is done to code, pull permits, as required, etc. Oh, and I wholeheartedly agree with Kate: What a sweetheart house!

kateBack to Kate: I hope I’ve given you a few ideas you can use Ashley! Please let us know what you end up doing to your porch!

Which solution do you prefer for Ashley’s porch?

Have you ever seen round, metal porch posts like this on a midcentury house?

design dilemma

Be-Safe-graphic2.3

Get our retrolicious free newsletter.

Newsletter-sign-up-2NMAS

Get our retrolicious free newsletter.

Comments

  1. says

    I’d probably box the poles them in myself. Same look, less work, expense, and overall long term maintenance.

    As for the design, I like the diamonds the best. That one has my favorite porch design (more cottage to my way of thinking, yet still in keeping with the ranch aesthetic). It’s jazzy, with great colors, and says ‘welcome home’.

    If I were to do the porch railings on the first, I’d probably use the diamond shutters and a windowless door, but I like an overall balance and symmetry (that’s one thing I’ve learned about myself over the years – I’m a very symmetrical kind of girl lol).

    Imo, with the landscaping, more is better. So many people with ranches do the bare minimum, leaving the house looking bare and uninviting (the previous owners of my own ranch did the same). Plantings soften a long walkway, so over time, I’d definitely plant a border along at least one side. 🙂

    Good luck in your decision, and have fun!

    • Tami says

      I mostly agree with the ‘more is better’ in landscaping. Those beds hugging the house are way too skimpy and look too much like ‘parsley around the Thanksgiving turkey.’ Plus, some of the plants chosen will grow too big for that space and will be in contact with the siding in just a few years. Definitely avoid that! Either widen those beds or choose different plants. One further thing: barberry is proving to be invasive in many locations so you might want to avoid it.

      Here’s an idea for less is more: how about planting boxes? A window box and a box along the porch railing with seasonal plantings might be cute and easy. Or put in a long planting box instead of railings . . . .

      • pam kueber says

        I read somewhere once: Size the depth of your beds to the height of the house (not the top of the roof, the siding part). This will make the house seem “grounded”. Literally. Made sense to me.

        • Lauryn says

          Do you size them 1:1? I like the idea of proportion, though 1:1 seems like a pretty big bed. We need to re-do our beds at some point and I’d like them to not overwhelm the house. (I think the previous owners planted shrubs that are way too big. Of course pruning them every once in awhile could help!)

  2. nina462 says

    I have a front porch as well, that has posts (4). Just by having the plants you’ll have privacy, so no need to add the fencing portion. I know, because I can sit my wicker rocker and ‘hide’ behind my rhodendron bush 🙂 in the corner.
    all of them look nice, but I don’t think you need the fence portion.

  3. says

    Paint the porch poles the same colour as the siding so they disappear from the street. Then don’t do anything else. I ripped all the railings off my porch. The top rail was at eye level and blocked my view of the street when sitting in my Adirondack chairs…and it felt like I was enclosed in a playpen. All my neighbours remarked it looked better with the railings down.

    • lynda says

      Painting is the easiest “fix” for the metal poles. I wonder if you could put some trellis up and train a clematis on one of the poles. Maybe the one closest to the drive would look nice that way. I also think it would look nice to have a fairly large garden area in front of the porch with some stepping stones from the driveway to the main walkway. A bench could even be in the garden area. Hanging window boxes on the railing would look very nice and add to the cottage garden look. However, if you don’t like to garden, this may not be the option for you.

  4. Jeanne2 says

    I think the porch rails really add a LOT to the look of this house. #1 is my favorite with one exception. ‘They’ say that a path/sidewalk should never curve without a reason. To me the lone, curvy walk looks more natural with the side plantings in number 3. Terrific job, Kate!

  5. says

    Oh, I just love these kinds of houses. My vote is for the Home on the Range, with the Diamonds being a close second. Nice mock-ups, Kate, and adorable house, Ashley!

  6. nancy says

    I have a house built in 1949 and also with a round metal porch post (only one in my asymmetrical porch roof). It’s the same with a few others in the neighborhood, so I think they are original. I promptly built boxes around them and it looks so much better!

    All three of the options look nice. Good luck.

  7. Ted says

    Kate, what great work! Not just Photoshop-wise, but design-wise as well. I agree w/ most all the good comments above, but to add:

    (1) The “Cute Cottage” version is my personal favorite.

    (2) Those simple round steel poles (usu. 3″ or 4″ dia.) absolutely were quite common ‘back in the day’…..certainly a well-used design element for midcentury MODERN homes (a trickle-down influence from architects like Le Corbusier and Gropius), but also, because of that observation Pam’s made often, of how merchant builders cobbled together various details they admired in magazines (and which incidentally fit nicely into their budgets) into the bulk of midcentury homes. (Not really much different today, to be honest.) So the mission of most any home make-over, as I see it, is to “help the house figure out what it really wants to be”….which is what your whole exercise here is doing.

    (3) I defin. agree to just wrap the pipes with 1-by press.-treated lumber (e.g. 1×6; 1×8) to make them square. (You’ll hafta use solid STAIN, not paint, for PT lumber.) Any decent contractor can determine that the pipes are still sound (not corroded or structurally compromised). Perhaps there’s some interesting detail on the house (not seen in the photo provided) that can be echoed for a subtle variation on simple square posts. I’d install small unobtrusive alum. vent grills (about the size of a half-dollar) flush in the tops of them (painted right over), and be sure to have them raised slightly so they don’t bear directly on the ground, to prevent rot; easy enough, since they won’t be load-bearing.

    (4) Even though the railing isn’t required (typically needed for 30″+ grade change, but of course check local Bldg. Code), I really DO like your addition of it; here’s why: (a) it gives more depth to the front elevation; (b) you can take advantage of it NOT being needed to detail it however you like — codes have ‘dumbed-down’ deck railing styles so much (e.g. 36″ ht.; no gap greater than 4″) that they’ve robbed them of most design options. But here, you’re free to use some kind of geometry like this that’s more creative….and you can make the height more-aesthetically-appropriate. (It really bugs me when I see 1920s/’30s-era Arts & Crafts Bungalows, of which there are a ton in my city, that are forced to replace the original lower porch railings with too-tall 36” ht. ones. PROPORTION is the winning element in design, that’s often overlooked or misunderstood.)

    (5) I don’t think ‘closing in’ the shallow porch w/ a railing should be a concern; to extend the porch floor further out to a more comfortable size would involve some complicated & maybe-not-desired expense for an appropriate roof style (probably shed roof), besides darkening the interior further.

    (6) Also, the railing makes it less obvious that you’ll only have shutters on that one other window. I like that you show them installed properly! (See RetroRenov article on “Curb Appeal with Shutters” from a couple of years ago.)

    (6) I agree the lampost is nice, but I think a more approp. & modest style would be a suitable replacement to this ornate Victorian one.

    (7) As far as landscaping I’ll only add (b/c this is already too long-winded!): (a) I agree a small flowering tree on R side of photo is desirable to soften out-of-scale neighbor’s tall blank wall; (b) deeper landscaped beds, of varying depth, would be an improvement; (c) go for a more massed look of limited qtys. of species but more of most; (d) I actually like the curved walk, in this case, and it [at least from the viewed angle of photo] seems to ‘work’ well to add depth & interest to small front yard.

  8. Alice says

    Kate, what a great job you did with your graphic examples…you make it LOOK easy! I really like the diamonds design…and the little added floating bed next to the walk is a classy touch.

  9. says

    I love all three, but prefer #1. (It reminds me of my neighbor’s darling house before they up and tore down the lovely porch railing and put up vinyl instead.)

    But….

    I’d base my choice on the rest of the neighborhood. If the neighborhood has more of a mid-century vibe, I’d choose the third one. More traditional, and I’d choose the first.

  10. Melissa Toombs says

    All three are well designed, so you can’t go wrong Ashley. Personally I love the diamonds in #3, but the aqua in number #1 makes my heart flutter! No matter what you decide, have fun with the word and enjoy the results.

  11. says

    I agree with the comment that questions the need for railings. The porch slab is at grade and the honesty of MCM shouldn’t add something that is not functionally required. I would suggest the the landscape plantings be pulled back from the house to create an entry garden space and let the metal pole do what it is supposed to do.

  12. TJ says

    I’d be really interested in what you might suggest for the mid-century duplexes that are EVERYWHERE in Washington, DC. We recently bought one built in 1947, and I’d love to stay true to the spirit of the era as we spruce it up (although thankfully the metal awnings are long gone), but can’t find ideas anywhere.

  13. Mary says

    I wasn’t sure where else I should ask this, after combing the site and finding this cute little house that reminds me of my own…. what is a suitable siding replacement? We have wide aluminum that has not been well cared for and we’d like to replace it. I hardly think its original. Tips? Suggestions?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *