Our tutorial and 30+ tips to make your own vintage Christmas ornament wreath

How to make vintage ornament wreath

I have been ornie hoarding for a few years… and we have Georgia Peachez’ DIY instructions… so I invited my friend Danielle (above) to my house so we could conquer wreath-making together. It was super fun! Our wreaths turned out gorgeous! I am now obsessed with these wreaths! Read on for our 30+ tips to make an ornament wreath of your very own -> 

 christmas ornament wreathhow-to-make-vintage-ornament-wreath

How to make a vintage Christmas ornament wreath:

    1. Step One — Gather Supplies
    2. vintage christmas ornamentsYou need vintage ornaments and lots of them. My wreath included 75 ornaments. Danielle used 95 ornaments. I used fewer because the ornaments in my chosen colorways were larger, based on the supply I had available. Danielle used more, because a lot of the ornaments in pinks were smaller.
    3. You need vintage ornaments in a variety of sizes. You need big ones for the exterior ring. You need medium-sized for the center wing. You need all sizes for the top layers, although I did not feel that large ones worked so well on the top layer, as they tended to overwhelm. And also really key: Tiny ones to fill in little open spaces and add whimsy-doodle to the front of wreath.
    4. Different shapes are good, too — bells, lanterns, teardrops, the kind with concave thingies in them… different shapes, sizes, textures all add dimension and visual interest.
    5. You need vintage Christmas weebits — I had one knee-hugger elf, but beyond that, I was way short of little somethings to add.
    6. We used 14″ foam wreath forms. I found the best selection at Michael’s. My JoAnn’s did not have the 14″, only 12″ and that looked too small. Michael’s also had a 16″, but golly we were worried about running out of ornaments as it was. JoAnn’s seemed a little cheaper, by $1 per wreath or so, but again,  it did not have as many sizes.
    7. The only place I could find the silver garland I wanted was Wal-Mart. It was 97 cents for 15′. The garland I wanted was not “supersized” (argh!), but rather the modest size that I remember as a child. We used about 20′ of garland per 14″ wreath — so buy extra. Note, eyeballing Georgia Peachez’ wreaths, I think she uses the supersized kind — so that’s okay too.
    8. BUT big tip on garland size: Georgia Peachez says I should not have used the dinky thin old school garland!!! See her comments below. The chunkier garland that she recommends seems to sell for about $3.50 a 15′ strand. To use next year, I am going to buy a bunch at big discount after the holidays.
    9. Supplies and product to hang the wreath. We used picture-frame looped eye rings — two per wreath, with a piece of picture wire hung between them. You will need a wire-cutter to trim the picture wire. BUT, note that Georgia Peachez uses a different method — see her tips below.
my new glue gun

I’m a big gun now: Just bought this bigger glue gun, which has very good reviews on Amazon. Georgia Peachez will approve.

  1. High-heat hot glue gun and glue sticks. I used a standard high heat mini glue gun that I purchased at a local craft store, and it seems to have worked well. But now that I have the bug bite bad, I have purchased this Surebonder HE-750 Professional High Temp 2 Heater Glue Gun (affiliate link), which seems to have received a lot of good reviews including for its high heat (BE CAREFUL!). This came in the mail over the weekend — and it looks really substantial. I have planned an activity to make more wreaths with friends who are visiting for Thanksgiving — that’s why I ordered more glue guns. I will report back on how the Surebonder works then.
  2. Scissors to trim your garland and the strings from Christmas weebits.
  3. Cocktails. I had a screwdriver. Danielle, Jack Daniels. But don’t overdue it. You will be wielding a high temp hot glue gun — and you will want to keep your wits about you to ensure an artistic arrangement of your precious vintage ornaments.
  4. Snacks and music. Time to pull out the Christmas CDs. Be sure to include the Chipmunks — my personal #1.
  5. A nice big place to work — we used my dining room table, and a place to stage all your ornaments — an adjacent table or buffet or the link — nearby.
  6. DISCLAIMER: This is the first time we made these. Georgia Peachez’ instructions said high temp hot glue guns, and that’s what we used. We also double-dabbed for added security. But, we used thin garland, oops. Will our ornaments stay attached? We sure hope so!

The basic steps — illustrated — to make a vintage Shiny Brite ornament wreath:

shiny brite ornaments

Gather yee your ornies — all shapes, sizes, styles, colors. In this photo, I show you the SEVEN sizes of Shiny Brites that I have identified. I am finding the largest size hard to find for sale online…

vintage christmas ornaments

I staged the ornaments on the built-in bar next to my dining room table. Before we started, we each decided the ornament color combinations we would focus on. Because we had “only” 260 ornaments to work with, we needed to be sure that we would have enough to complete our designs. We divvied up these ornaments and put them right down on the dining room table with us, so that we could each see what we were working with as we went.

garland on wreath forms

First, though, gather your wreath forms, your garland, your glue gun and scissors. See my tips above on choosing garland — use the thicker, chunkier kind, Georgia Peachez advised me.

wrap wreath forms

Next, start wrapping the wreaths with tinsel. Wind the tinsel around the form… add dabs of glue as you go. I only put the glue on one side of the wreath form. It held really well. I don’t think you don’t need to go overboard with the glue.

add hooks

Once you have the forms wrapped in garland, it’s time to “choose” the back side and add your hanging apparatus. We used eye hooks that screwed in — two of them — then added picture wire. One thing we learned with this method: Make the hole for the eye hook, then, before you put the eye hook in, dollop the hot glue but good down in the hole. Screw in eye-hook thingie. Add more glue. You do not want your wreath to fall! Let glue dry completely then turn wreath back to front side for next step. TIP: NEXT TIME I MAKE A WREATH I WILL INSTALL THE HANGING APPARATUS BEFORE I WRAP THE FOAM CORE IN TINSEL. I think that THIS WILL MAKE IT EASIER TO SEE WHAT I AM DOING — AND GIVE ME MORE CONTROL OVER ‘ENSURING’ THE HANGING APPARATUS IS SECURE. Also note: Georgia Peachez uses a different hanging method, described in her tips, below.

creating vintage ornament wreathNow, start selecting the ornaments that you will use to ‘anchor’ the outside and inside rings of your wreath. (Although Georgia Peachez does not use an inside ring, see her tips below.) We used the largest ornaments on the outside. Medium-sized on the inside. To the degree you can keep the sizes uniform, it will be easier to keep the wreath a perfect circle. This is not essential, but I think it’s preferable — as I am so visually attuned to symmetry or the lack thereof. In our case, we did NOT have enough large to make the wreaths perfect circles on the outside ring. I played with the design to get a sort of pattern going (two larges/one not; repeat) and that worked. Another BIG TIP: Be very sensitive to the four ‘corners’ of your wreath and how it will look when hung. That is: What is sitting at 12 o’clock? At 6 o’clock? You might even want to mark 12 o’clock somehow, so that you don’t lose sight of how your emerging design ‘sits’.
make a vintage ornament wreath

Start gluing. In general, we used two dabs of hot glue on each ornament: #1 to secure it to the wreath substrate. #2 to secure it to the ornament adjacent — this seemed to add extra stability. Fortunately: The glue gun glue is darn forgiving: If a bit spider-webs, it pulls off the ornaments easily.

how to make a vintage ornament wreathI did the outside ring first. See how I had to alternate XL with L ornaments because I didn’t have enough XLs? Of course, I also tried to artistically arrange the colors. 
shiny-brite-wreath-500x333
Next comes the really fun part: Build up your wreath using the pretties, the weebits and then finish with the tiny balls. Sorry that I don’t have more photos of this process. I think I was so immersed in making the wreaths by this point. 
shiny brite ornamentsTip: Use “plain” vintage ornaments on the perimeter rings. Save your real stunners for the top. If something has words, for example, figure out how to use it to best effect in your design.
vintage-ornament-wreath-pink

Mix your sizes, shapes, colors, design, weebits and before you know it, you will be the proud creator of a STUNNING vintage ornament wreath! 

ornie-wreath

 #1 key: Have lots of ornaments and weebits to work with.

More tips to making ornament wreaths:

Danielle suggested:

  • I thought the building of little groupings and then filling in between them worked well for me.
  • Taking a break and stepping away would be good advice (wish I had done it more often–seeing those two little blue guys in the picture is bothering me–they stand out too much I think). And you can tell them I broke a couple but glued them back so they were hidden! :)
  • Oh, and the bit about seriously gluing the wire on the back, maybe even before the tinsel.

From me:

  • Super key is having a wide selection of ornaments and little trinkets to work with.
  • If you are hunting vintage Christmas ornaments on ebay or etsy, here are the brands I was able to identify: Shiny Brite, Coby, Bradford, Paragon, Commodore. Of course, also use search words Vintage and Old. These things are expensive online — and it takes many ornaments to do a wreath! I can most definitely understand why buying a complete wreath from masters like Georgia Peachez now cost $250.
  • Think carefully about your color selection. An easy rule, if you are nervous about this step: Use two closely-related col0rs (blue & green, pink & hot pink were our choices, based on our ornament supply) and then mix them with silver and gold. Warning: Every time you add one more color, you may be reducing the visual drama of the wreath (and vice versa). I have seen examples of wreaths that use “all colors” or “more color” and they can be gorgeous, too. I’m just saying that, in general, if you are nervous, editing your palette is a more assured way of getting great results.
  • Identify your “big winner” ornaments for the front of the wreath — make sure you give them the most prominent position — build the other elements around them. Clear case in point: Knee-hugger elf should be a star of your wreath!
  • Tilt or angle your knee-hugger elf or other trinkets. The arrangement of the ornaments is not linear.
  • If you have three of something special, put them together. Notice: My three bells and Danielle’s three hot-pink teardrop thingies. Massing of smaller elements like this — in particular in threes — works very effectively.
  • Don’t worry about having the metal parts of the ornaments showing on the front of the wreath. Sometimes I’d have them hidden or tucked under, sometimes I would have them show. I like the patina of the old metal…
  • Don’t worry about having the tinsel underneath show. You don’t want large gaps, though — play with your ornament configurations before committing, and be sure to have a big stash of the tiny orbs before you get going!
  • Invite a friend — double the fun!

Tips from Suzy of Georgia Peachez herself!

So then, I asked the Queen — Suzy of Georgia Peachez — to read this entire tutorial, and if she had time, to provide any pearls. And oh so generously, she did! Here is what she wrote:

Oh my, that was quite an undertaking, writing that tutorial. Bravo, well done, and the wreaths too. OK, so here are my “pearls” of wisdom, all from hard earned experience (and sometimes pain induced too). No particular order here:

  • I do a very simple wire hook on my wreaths. I cut floral wire about 14″ long, bend in half to make a loop, put behind wreath, bring legs around and thru to front and over again to the back, wrap each around loop. Done. This is after tinsel wrapping. Virtually disappears when hung on wall because you are so stunned by the magnificence of the wreath :->
  • Big Lots is another good source for tinsel.
  • I always use thick, shaggy tinsel. Ornies grip it better. Thin, pitiful tinsel is a bad move.
  • I see you have used one of those weenie little glue guns. You can get a decent full size gun for high temp gluing at Joann’s for $20, less the coupon they constantly have, so it is very reasonable at $10-12. No one should ever use those wussy guns for anything. Man up and get a full size gun. I use a commercial grade gun and glue for obvious reasons.
  • High temp glue is absolutely CRITICAL.
  • I don’t put ornies around the middle of the ring. Doesn’t work for me, makes it harder to design on top. Many times what I’m placing on top needs to hang a bit into that center space. I don’t recommend it.
  • Yes, sometimes ornies pop off. The glue just pulls the paint right off of certain ornies. Just reglue it. No biggie. I have wreaths in my collection from years ago and they are just fine. I store them in the attic too.
  • Don’t recommend displaying wreaths outside or even on a porch. I think the cold would shrink the glue too much and then you might get more pop offs. I don’t do it, so I don’t speak from experience here.
  • I make mostly multi color wreaths, but composition is everything. The colors must balance, everything must balance. Lop-sided wreaths make my OCD tendencies flare up real bad. Your instructions on that were spot on.
  • Advise readers: Don’t glue vintage ornaments to an evergreen wreath form. DON’T DO IT. They do not hold up over time.
  • I’ve worked hard to build my brand and wreath business. I work like a dog making as many wreaths as I can because the demand is overwhelming. A very good dilemma to have! The demand is so great that I purchase vintage ornies in bulk and often pay a premium. I will pay up to $4 each for exceptional ones and each wreath has 80-100 ornaments. Elves have gotten crazy expensive too. I use every size from 1/4″ and up to fill in all the gaps. Wreath forms are expensive! I buy in bulk, but they still aren’t cheap.

Look forward to the post on Monday.

xo, suzy

Kate made a video!

Want to preserve your vintage ornaments?

  • For the outside and inside rings (if you do an inside rings), only use plain ornaments. These plain shinys tend to be much more widely available — including from the 1980s from stores like Bradlees and W.T. Grant. I was not a stickler for “Shiny Brites” per se. I was happy to find and use any vintage ornaments from any maker. Key to me was that they were old — and that they had patina. I am soooo into patina.
  • That said, if you are not an absolutely stickler for vintage, you can further extend your use of vintage ornaments by using new ornaments for the outside and/or inside rings. Save your decorative vintage ornaments for the highly-visible top part of the wreath.
  • This week I also plan on testing some techniques to faux-age inexpensive, brand new-ornaments to use on the outer rings.  Stay tuned.

Buy a wreath from the Queen o’ Wreath Making, Georgia Peachez:

We hear from readers, who made wreaths using our tips:

shiny bright ornament wreathchristmas ornament wreath

Reader Erin (above) wrote:

We did it! Our wreaths turned out great. We are so pleased with the results, and we could not have completed this without your detailed directions. I can’t thank you enough for the blog post preview.

I’ve attached pictures of me (Erin), my sister (Andrea), and her weebit (Lenny)…and of course, our wreaths.
We had such a fun day working on this project together.

Thank you for doing what you do!

You’re welcome, Erin! And weebit Lenny: Cute overload! xoxo

ornament-wreaths

Above: Another ornament wreath that Pam made a few weeks later.

Get our retrolicious free newsletter.

Newsletter-sign-up-2NMAS

Comments

  1. says

    Read the tutorial and comments ….. and I have a question about the size of the tinsel. 3 inches in length? And I have the crazy idea to try the mock up with new ornies so might try gold tinsel in place of the silver tinsel on a purple, red and gold scheme.

    • pam kueber says

      Hi Alice, this is Pam with a broken arm on Siri. I personally do not recommend the giant Normas stencil. You’d use the old-fashioned shorter tensile like we used to have in the way back Time Machine days. Also, use the search or you may see it in the right-hand column of this post., But I did a full story on using new ornaments and where to get them etc. that also worked really well for me. Be sure to see the story I think you will enjoy it good luck start taking pictures want to see him come Christmas time

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *