Adventures in decorating: Will Margie ever find the perfect Mamie pink paint?

pink paint swatchesFinding the just-right paint color can be such an arduous process. Margie struggled for a solid year to find the perfect pink paint (or would she go for wallpaper??) for her original Mamie pink bathroom. Would she ever find it? (Hint: In the end, she took matters into her own hands.)

vintage pink bathroomI’ve actually been in contact with Margie for the better part of a year, as she continued a tenacious quest to find just-the-right wall treatment for her vintage pink half bathroom.

After considering everything from vintage wallpaper to several different colors of paint, Margie found inspiration from Jane’s pink and green bathroom. Margie liked the idea of Jane’s ‘Apricot Fluff’ walls… but she had found another pink she also liked. So, she combined the two ideas….

midcentury pink paint

Margie documented her saga for us — we suspect this is similar to what many of us do on the path to finding “perfect” wall treatments:

Hi Kate and Pam,

Just over a year ago, I told you about a paint color that almost exactly matches my 1957/58 pink half bath tile. It’s PPG Porter Paints’ “Sonia Rose.” I looked through a LOT of pinks to find it! 

pink and grey vintage bathroom

I used it to paint a metal shelf (above) in my bathroom but felt the paint color was too intense to use on the walls in such a small (4’3″ x 4’3″) room. I looked into wallpaper since I know the kitchen, full bath, and this half bath had been papered originally, and I’d even found a sliver of a tropical green and pink paper that I suspect might be original to the half bath. But I wasn’t happy with any paper I saw, either vintage or new.

Then I tried a grey paint for a while, and that wasn’t working, either. I removed the original interior window shutters to have them stripped and when I did that, the trim paint was ruined, so I needed to strip and repaint the trim. I tested for lead (none) and stripped the window frame and sill completely. When I started looking closer at all the trim and door paint, it was so lackluster and even seemed to be a sort of grey-white. I cleaned it and cleaned it and it never got whiter, so now I’ve repainted all the trim in the room and will (eventually) do a lot of trim repainting throughout the house.  I had my original red oak floors refinished (Early American stain–it looks fabulous) in November, new shoe molding went down, and I have to touch up all the baseboards in the house, so this is a long-term job.

vintage green and pink bathroom

Jane’s pink and green bathroom with Apricot Fluff wall paint was the inspiration for Margie’s custom mixed pink paint.

After seeing and loving Jane’s pink and green bathroom, I was inspired and thought maybe “Apricot Fluff” would work in my room, but it’s just a little too peachy for my pink tile.

visual gravity

To create her paint color, Margie used a tried-and-true trick: Find a paint color that matches your tile exactly, then tint it — add white — til you get the effect you want. This also ensures good “visual gravity” — one of the concepts we explore in our guide, A Foolproof Guide to Choosing Bathroom Colors — Five Secrets to Success.

 So I decided to buckle down and mix up my own shade, which turned out to be about 25 parts white to 1 part Sonia Rose. I am so happy with it and wanted to show it off to you.

1950s pink bathroom

vintage pink floor tile

The bathroom still has its original floor tile, a dapple-finish hex tile similar to this square tile on King of Thrones.

vintage Miami Carey bathroom mirror

Thought you’d also like to know that the medicine cabinet is the original Miami-Carey, and the light switch glows when turned off. They installed the switch box too low, so I’ve had to cut the plate to make it fit above the tile.  The only plug in the room is on the light fixture. If I did anything to remodel the room, it would be to move the switch box up and enlarge it to fit a switch+plug set.

The vintage lamp on the tank lid has a pink glass cup, perfect for storing cotton balls. I got the original lingerie sketches from a seller at Atlanta’s Scott Antique Market a couple of years ago. And I just installed a new, old-style light fixture to replace the single-bulb light that was in there. One day, I’ll find a more decorative shade for it on eBay.

pink bathroom

I made the valence to match the vanity curtain, but when I held up the fabric to look at making a matching window curtain, the room just looked like an old-tyme soda shoppe. So I got some whiter fabric that looks nicer with the whiter-white trim paint and made a new curtain. It’s clearly easy to overdo such a small space, which is why I was concerned about pink wall paint when this all started, and why I wasn’t happy with most wallpapers.

Margie, your pink bathroom looks fantastic — we love the pinks together, along with simple elegance of the pink paired with black and white decor — classique. In a small space like our bathrooms, sometimes the best bet is to use colors that have high Light Reflective Values (LRVs) to bounce light around the room and make it feel lighter, brighter and more spacious. Also, you know what Pam says about pink: It’s Retro Botox — it takes 10 years off, what with the rosy glow — great place to take portrait shots!

Thanks for sharing your fun paint-journey story!

More stories about pink bathrooms:

Be-Safe-graphic2.3

Get our retrolicious free newsletter.

Newsletter-sign-up-2NMAS

Get our retrolicious free newsletter.

Comments

  1. Beverly says

    Paint selection is a brutal process–at least it is for me. I either have a precise idea of what I want, then can find nothing that is suitable, or I see so many things that could work then can’t make up my mind.

    Congratulations to Margie.

  2. Ruth Ann Kuntz says

    A mono chromatic color scheme is probably the hardest to achieve. The color tints need to be consistent and not have extreme cool and warm tones mixed. They will feel off and you may not notice the temperature clash is the problem. Also light, bright and dark are needed. Rather it is a high, low or medium contrast. Your end result is beautiful and warm. Well worth the time.

  3. Carolyn says

    Now watch, she’ll be toodling along in a store, looking for something else entirely, and her eye will catch on a bazillion (rough estimate) paint chips of “her” color. Or it’ll be featured in all the decorating/home magazines.

    • Margie says

      Speaking of spotting pinks, I was at Lowe’s the other day and among their HGTV Home/Sherwin-Williams colors, I spotted SW0026 “Rachel Pink” and SW6323 “Romance” which are close contenders for Mamie Pink bathrooms. Rachel Pink has slightly more peachy tones in it than Sonia Rose, but it’s very similar. Romance has a beige tone to it but is very pretty.

  4. Trudi says

    What a lovely room! We have a store nearby that carries them but I’ve never used PPG Porter paints. Can you compare them to another brand in ease of use, price?

    • Dana says

      PPG paint is now the only paint I will use (interior – Silken Touch). It is more expensive, but the best quality – thick, superior coverage, incredibly durable, especially in bathrooms and kitchens and with kids! Well worth the price.

  5. Margie says

    PPG Porter Paints are perhaps a tiny bit more expensive than basic-level Lowe’s, but I like their tint variety and I’m pleased with the quality. Since the can sat so long, I had the shop shake it again before I started mixing. This room doesn’t have the same RH/water issues as a full bath, so I wasn’t worried too much about extremes of wear or cleaning where a really expensive paint might help. The qt. of Sonia Rose I got when I painted the shelf was an eggshell finish & I added flat white. I’d tried just eggshell with the grey for reflection but wasn’t happy with that look (plus the cool/warm issues) and really wanted the saturation of flat with this pink. And adding a two-bulb light fixture to replace the one-bulb fixture really helps in this north-facing room. I love RR’s color rules, and I worried that too much bright white would cool the pink, to much so I added a tiny bit of Sherwin-Williams “Cream” (what the main walls in the house are) to add back some warmth. In testing, too much Cream made the mix too peachy, so I had to be careful with it, but that little dab did do it!

  6. Mary Elizabeth says

    Congratulations, Margie, for finding your own solution. The pink you finally mixed came out looking like my childhood bedroom, which my dad and I painted together when I was about 12. When I was picking out the color, he told me, “Pick out the color you think you like, then pick a lighter shade of the same color. Then we’ll try it on a patch of one wall, and if it still is too dark, I’ll add white to it.” I’ve never gone wrong with his advice–on paint or any other topic, now that I think of it. 🙂

  7. Carol says

    When looking for paint colors, ask to see the Architectural Book – it has every shade in between all the colors on the paint chips. All paint counters used to have one, but now these books are usually only found at stand alone company paint stores.

    This may make your search a bit easier and less time consuming!

  8. says

    I’m a Realtor in suburban Detroit. We have some ab fab old homes. Mine was built in ’36. I often come across pink bathrooms. More often than I like, potential buyers say “Ugh, that would have to go.” THAT is when I hold forth and extol the virtues of this web site. I’m on a mission to save as many pink bathrooms as I can. One of my clients found ‘save the pink bathrooms” on this site a few years ago and sent it to me. HE was ready to gut his, until he found that site. Now, he proudly brags about bring his pink back to life. Happy Days!

  9. Joe Felice says

    The pink walls coordinate perfectly, but, honestly, I liked the gray better. Too much tone-on-tone for me. Maybe a row of black bullnose would have helped. But it turned out well and the way she wanted, and that is the important thing.

    Pink, and its derivatives from red to orange, is a tough color to get just right. It is precisely the red in it that makes this so. And then the tone changes slightly depending on the light, the surrounding coordinates, the surface, and the sheen. It, indeed, can be very tough getting just that right shade. I think maybe that’s why people (back then and today) just say “Forget it,” and go with wallpaper.

  10. linoleummy says

    Everything, Margie, from the tone on tone walls & floor to the valance & curtains to the tiny black accents is just deliciously perfect.

  11. Margie C. says

    Update: Benjamin Moore has a couple of pink/peach-ish colors that are very close to the color I ended up with by mixing. “Sun Washed” 2169-70, and “Soft White” 2170-70.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *