Gerry salvages a house full of gorgeous vintage knotty pine — pickwick pine even!

Don’t want your knotty pine, America? We have readers who do! Gerry writes:

Hello. I just finished salvaging a truckload of beautiful Pickwick style Knotty Pine paneling from a 1950s beach cottage that was being torn down. I was really excited to find the information contained on your site regarding the history of this product. I am going to re-purpose it in the sun porch of my own beach bungalow . It has a beautiful original amber finish on it, and I hope to cherry pick the nicest boards so I can install it just as found without any refinishing.

Nom nom, Knotty is Nice! I write back to Gerry tout suit. He quickly responds:

Hi Pam. I am a big fan of your site, I have referenced it many times over the years, so I should not have been surprised you had all the info on knotty pine paneling. It certainly was a popular choice for the homes built along the Jersey coast as far back as the 1930s and well into the 1960’s.

Above: Here are some of the photos of the paneling still in the original house before it was torn down. Notice the random board widths ranging from 4″ to 10″…

Above: Loaded up in the bed of my truck…

Above: Potlatch Lumber (Washington State) was founded in 1903 and is still in business, although I think the company has been sold a couple times. Might still be a good source for knotty pine.

These photos shows a nice view of the Pickwick profile milled into the tongue and groove boards:

Laying out the boards in my garage to “cherry pick” the nicest ones for my project:

Has a nice vintage “amber glow” to it that is just right. Not too dark or light. Great character in the “knots” too and lots of them! It’s also almost twice as thick as the 5/16″ thick panels commonly found in the big box stores now. I think it would be hard to duplicate this paneling using today’s materials. Plan is to use it “as-is, as found” without any sanding or re-finishing.

Can’t wait to install it and rub it down with it’s first coat of Liquid Gold polish. I love the smell of that stuff !

Hope you like the pictures.

Gerry C. from the Jersey Shore

I don’t like the pictures, Gerry — I love them! Thanks for sharing! And of course, we’d love to see photos of the paneling reinstalled when you are ready for prime time. Thanks so much for sharing!

Categoriesknotty pine
  1. Alexander McCartney says:

    I’ve used your article looking for the the correct pattern. IN fact your site was why I know my pattern number. Also learned that I have panels that are almost impossible to find. I love the look of the knotty pine kitchen. Also two walls in my dining/living room have them painted, it looks great. I just wish I can find some boards to make my kitchen look like it did.

  2. Pam Kueber says:

    I am not an expert, but think a wood-making company should be able to make you the profile you want if you have a sample they could work with… ?

  3. Tucker says:

    A mill shop can have a cutter made to match the profile either from a drawing or a wood sample. It is run on a
    wood shaper or a molding machine. The cost is having the cutter made and machine set up which would be a few hundred dollars depending on the type of machine. Then the cost of materials and running the machine
    Check around shops have cutters from previous jobs. I have a similar profile from years ago when I probably ran under 500 feet. Larger shops might have multiple similar profiles of this type
    Getting the proper wood depending on area if not paint grade could be another matter. I will look in my cutter cabinet to see what I have.

  4. Alexander McCartney says:

    I looked into milling, the place tlod me no problem then to make the blade by measuring the cabinet door without damaging it. Then I get a call 3 hours later, they wanted to cut one of my cabinet doors in half. Well that made me go get the door. The other issue is the white pine looks different now and would not match well, my best bet is to find old stock

  5. Christi Furth says:

    I have the same exact paneling in my basement in Roebling NJ. My house was built in 1959. I love it. It’s beautiful.

  6. Mary Porter says:

    I am having this installed in my soon to be sunroom of my 1955 ranch. Memories of the living room in my parents old house. My father put this up at some point in 1970. It aged to that rich dark honey. 2012 my mom passed. My sister donated the house to Habitat for Humanity. They gutted it. Offered me the boards. I couldn’t use them at that time. I now want to kick myself. This stuff needs to age. It needs love. Adore it…

Leave a Reply

Commenting: Information

All comments are moderated, generally within 24 hours. By using this website you are agreeing to the site's >> Terms of Service, << which include commenting policies, and our >> Privacy Notice. << Before participating, read them in full.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.