Harmonizing midcentury modern paint colors — Ashley wants our help

DesignDilemmaReader Ashley loves bright colors and retro style. Though her house was built in the 1930s and originally a country style, she wants her great room to have a more 50s/60s vibe — at least in her kitchen/dining/living room area. She’s painted the built-in shelves a burnt orange to match her vintage modern sectional couch and even put up — yes, I said put up — wood paneling along the front wall. With a new Big Chill fridge and some Youngstown vintage steel cabinets waiting to be painted, Ashley needs our help to pull it all together and create her retro modern dream room.

mid-century-great-roomvintage-living-roomAshley writes:

Hey Pam,
First off I just want to say that your site is amazing and I cant even tell you how much this has helped me in the past few years. THANK YOU!

(I apologize in advance because this will be long) I don’t know where to start so I will just tell you everything….

I live in Alabama and we bought our house a little over a year ago. We wanted a more midcentury modern style house but we needed acreage for my husband’s business and shop so unfortunately we were not able to get that. Our home was built in the early 30s and is more of a country style home (I am not complaining anything old is better than new in my book) and has been updated and added on to several times. It has a very open floor plan and the den, dinning room and kitchen are all connected and technically one room.

retro-vintage-kitchenI bought my second set of Youngstown cabinets yesterday after almost a year of searching and need to decide how to do the kitchen to where it will still go with the rest of the connecting rooms and have the mcm look I am going for.

retro-refrigeratorWe painted the den and built ins, put up wood paneling, bought furniture all when we moved in and recently bought a BIG CHILL fridge in jadeite green. With all that being said…Now I am looking at these rooms as a whole and I am not sure what I have done. Are the colors all from the same decade, does my fridge go with my couch and have I wasted all his money and ended up with a disaster. EKKKKK!!!!

vintage-modern-kitchenI am so overwhelmed! I hope that made sense.

mid-century-dining-tableI have attached photos of our den/dinning/kitchen area and photos of the couch, Big Chill Fridge and my drexel dining table. (Those three pieces have to stay) I also want to keep the same color palette pretty much, but I know something needs to be tweaked (just not sure what). I have no idea and I dont want to just start changing things and still not get it right especially since we are about to have our Youngstown cabinets repainted and installed along new laminate countertops.

mid-century-vintage-living-roommid-century-retro-kitchenI am struggling with:

mid-century-modern-couchWhat color to paint my youngstown cabinets and what style and color of laminate to choose that will go with my jadeite fridge and burnt orange/red couch. (The cabinets that are currently in are painted jocular green by sherwin williams and the match the fridge exactly, I had originally planned on doing that color on the youngstown cabinets, but unsure if that really goes with the rest of the space.)

I obviously need to repaint the mustard room past the den…so should I paint it the same color (vegan sherwin williams) as the den and kitchen or change the color all together.

vintage-modern-living-roomLastly, the built-in shelves that flank the fireplace and are in the mustard room (are actually the same color as the couch but the pictures make it look a little brighter than they truly are) not sure if those should be muted down?

Geeze Louise this is long and I hope it makes sense. Cant wait to hear back!

Thanks so much in advance.

Ok readers — let’s give Ashley some ideas. How can she tweak her large space to all coordinate and look more cohesive?

Kate’s advice:

Ashley’s large great room area — including kitchen, dining room, living room and den — has a lot going on and is a big space to plan. I can see why Ashley is stuck — she has several angled walls where they meet the ceiling, long walls that connect rooms, pieces of wall that jut out and have cut outs and lots of corners. My advice for you Ashley — simplify.

kitchen-vintageLet’s start with the kitchen. I think having your Youngstown steel cabinets painted to match that stunner of a Big Chill refrigerator that you have is a great idea. In fact, the color you are thinking about painting your Youngstown cabinets is close to the Sherwin Williams “mint condition” color that I painted my kitchen cabinets. What I think needs to happen on the walls though, is to first — paint the angled bits of wall that meet the ceiling the same color white as the ceiling. Before, when they were bright green, it was drawing too much attention to this portion of the wall — taking away from your cool fridge and cabinets. By painting it white, it will blend in and allow the true focus to be where it should be — on your soon-to-be awesome kitchen.

Next, I would pick a color that relates to your dark orange couch and painted built-ins (hard for me to recommend one since the oranges look so different in every photo) but is several shades lighter. Maybe a coral or peach depending on the specific orange on your couch. Get a bunch of coral and peach swatches and hold them up next to your couch and built-ins to see which one looks best. Then, I would use that color to paint the wall between the bottom of the cabinets and counter top. This will bring some warmth into your kitchen to help it coordinate with the rest of the rooms. Before, with the green on green color scheme, it felt too monochromatic and too “cold” next to the warm burnt orange of your sofa and built-ins.

For counter tops, I would choose a warm neutral laminate with a linen look — like Arborite Weathered Hemp or Earthen Hemp. Get samples of both and see which one coordinates best with your neutral tile floor and wood floor. This will add further warmth to the space, as well as some subtle texture to add interest. Since you have some chrome on your refrigerator and possibly cabinet handles — you could use metal edging like Pam used in her kitchen to complete the look.

Dining-room-retroI would continue the peachy-coral paint into the dining room. The warm color will look great with your warm wood Drexel dining set and wood floors.

Retro-Modern-living-roomFor the living room, continue the same peachy-coral color on the walls. The warm color will look great with the wood paneling, fireplace and other burnt orange pieces in the room. I’d add a neutral area rug — like this one from IKEA — in front of the sofa to visually anchor it and break up the large expanse of wood flooring. Then find a vintage coffee table, like this round Lane model, so you have somewhere to set your drinks. You could also add a few light neutral and light green throw pillows to your couch to bring the kitchen color out into your room. All of these touches will also make your room feel cozier.

Continuing through the room, I would paint all the bump outs near the ceiling the same white like in the kitchen, to draw attention away from them and towards the other elements in the room.

In your den room (previously yellow), you could paint The walls the Sherwin Williams Vegan green that you used before, then paint the built-in the same color as your kitchen cabinets. Put some orange pillows on your futon and a few orange/peachy things on your shelf and you’ll have a space that uses all of your favorite colors in a pleasing and cohesive arrangement.

Pam’s advice:

Ashley, your Design Dilemma inspires me to offer some theoritical design advice: There is, I believe, a “logical” order to making design decisions about a room. Fundamentally, the most expensive decisions are the most important ones. You nail these down before progressing to less expensive decisions. More expensive = hard to change, you want to be very careful, very thoughtful, because unless you are made of money, you want to be able to live with these decisions a long time. Less expensive = easy to change. Repita: The order in which you make design changes: Expensive first, Inexpensive after.

In regards to your design dilemma, I would advise: Do NOT get hung up on the color of your walls — until you have the more expensive designs made first. Wall color is relatively cheap and easy to change — while kitchen cabinets, countertops, refrigerators etc. ARE NOT.

Here is a stab at identifying which expenses fall into which bucket:

Expensive — focus on these first:

  • Architectural changes to the house — moving walls, moving windows, moving doors, etc.
  • Kitchen cabinets
  • Kitchen countertops and tile backsplashes
  • Kitchen floors
  • Kitchen appliances
  • Large pieces of new furniture
  • Custom window treatments

Inexpensive — focus on these after:

  • Paint color
  • Used furniture
  • Accessories
  • Rugs

In the case of your specific questions and dilemmas, Ashley, here is what I think I might do:

  • You did not ask about this — so I realize this is unsolicited advice — my apologies! — but I question the fact that your front door seems to be opening into the smack dab middle of your living room. To me, this placement looks like it is disturbing furniture flow and use of the room. And, it means there is no real foyer area to welcome guests, to put down their bags, etc. You said that the house has been added on to over time, and I am guessing that the den is an add on. My suggestion, if it is possible, is to consider moving the front door either closer to the den, or closer to the kithen; then add a half-wall to compartmentalize it, and the,n move forward with the design of the living room. Admittedly, though, I can’t really see the entire situation. This is just a thought. But I think you get my idea — this is an issue of “fixing the architecture” that I might deal with first, before moving forward on aesthetic issues.retro kitchen
  • For the kitchen, you have already locked into one expensive piece — the jadeite Big Chill refrigerator. So, this is now a starting point for the next steps in your kitchen. I do not think I would go with cabinets painted to match the fridge. I think it would be better to go with another color — one that would make the Big Chill fridge pop like the beautiful hunka hunka that it is.  I have seen ONE example of jadeite greenish steel cabinets here. I like how they appear darker than the jadeite of the sink — and presumably, darker than your fridge. You could also go with white cabinets. Maybe you don’t even need to repaint them if you stick with white? Can you “restore” them in the same way auto collectors polish up vintage cars? Just be sure to test for lead paint first and if it’s there, take precautions accordingly; consult your own properly licensed professional.
    How the jadeite Big Chill looks with white cabinets — click to see the story on this kitchen

    Emily’s jadeite kitchen cabinets — believed to be original finish
  • For countertops, I would consider something wood-look to bring warmth to all the metal in your kitchen. Wood-look countertops also would relate to the wood tones through the rest of the open concept area adjacent. How about Formica’s Butcher Block laminate. I would not edge them in metal, I would choose a simple postformed edge. And here’s another idea I have been toying with lately — real maple was used on countertops in the 1940s. How about maple laminate? Or, if you want to keep the wood tones darker to coordinate with your Drexel and your wall paneling, how about a wood toned laminate in the Drexel shades? I also like the idea of a woodtone countertop because you are mid century in the country.
  • For flooring, how about my kitchen floor, Azrock Cortina Autumn Haze. I think that would look quite nice. Alternatively, look at the sheet linoleum from Forbo and go with a light marbleized linoleum. I just read Jane Powell’s book linoleum (affiliate link) this weekend. A must-have for any Retro Renovator’s collection! She makes a very compelling case for the environmental benefits of true linoleum vs. flooring that contains vinyl/PVC.
  • For paint color for the wall, I went with Kate’s suggestion. And, I tied all the colors together with barkcloth from Melinamade.
  • In the living room, I would nix the burnt orange paint on the bookshelves. They are just too much. I love the Jerry Seinfeld gag where he says that when he has a killer headache, he wants to take just enough aspirin to kill him — then back it off. Same deal with the old saw: When you are getting all dolled up for a night on the town, the minute before you are walking out the door, check yourself in the mirror and take one piece of jewelry off. These cabinets are your aspirin, your one-bling-too-many.  Either strip them and stain them to match your paneling or Drexel, or use a product like Rustoleum Cabinet Transformation to mimic that wood look. I would likely finish the bookshelf in the den the same way, for visual continuity since you have one large open space.
  • I agree with Kate about repainting the mansard parts of the ceiling white rather than a color.
  • You have a big investment in the sectional. So that stays.
  • Paint color for the walls, room to room to room? Once you have all the expensive decisions outlined above completed, the paint colors should come relatively easy. I like Kate’s ideas a lot — as they keep the paint colors in the families of the larger decisions. One final note, the rug to go under the sectional could/should tie all the principal colors of the entire connected space together. It will need to contain shades of jadeite green, burnt orange, light and dark woodtones… I would not make it too light and bright. It should read dark to settle the space.  Maybe a large oval chenille braided rug in a principally brown colorway, with these other colors speckled in. This would also be cozy to lay on, and it has a little bit of country in it, too.

Good luck, Ashley. We congratulate you for being bold with color — you are close! Let us know what you decide!


  1. tammyCA says:

    I think the “open concept” makes it difficult when you love color. Back in the ’30s-’50s the rooms were separated..kitchens & dining rooms were their own separate boxes..and so the different room colors (those great vintage colors) weren’t competing with each other because they had their own individual walls.
    ‘Tho I love all your colors I think you have to limit them in such openness. The kitchen blue/green walls look too “cold” for a kitchen so maybe warm them up with soft yellow…then the Big Chill can be the spot of green with other jadeite accents.
    It looks like a skylight in the kitchen which to me always casts an odd light in my experience. I love lots of natural light thru lots of windows but not overhead..it never feels warm & natural to me.

  2. Amy Richcreek says:

    Congrats on the very cool home and open spaces! I agree with Pam on going with a warm ivory (or pale warm gray) on your kitchen cabinets to pop the Jadeite Big Chill. However, I would leave the angled wall in the kitchen near the ceiling in jadeite (or maybe mix jadeite & ceiling white) – then put a collection of copper kitchen molds on it.
    The mustard color is clashing and creating too much contrast; too much yellow going on. When I’m in a quandry, I go back to the basic color wheel (a good one is on: go to interiorscapespainting.com) The look you are going for uses a split complement color scheme (a primary color with 2 accent colors). Using jadeite green as your primary color, the wheel directs us to red orange and red-violet as the complementary colors. Say what? Trust the color wheel, it cannot tell a lie. It’s objective and puts the “science” in the art & science of color. Now go to Shewinwilliams.com, check out “Today’s Colors” and under that heading a palette called “Vintage Moxie”. Use the color visualizer will help you adjust for brighter, less red, more red, etc. Close to jadeite (for computer viewing) I found:
    “Aloe” (jadeite)
    “Beguiling Mauve” (soft grayed red-violet)
    “Innocence” (pale tint of red-orange)
    “Sunset” (red-orange)

    One other thing, pick your fabric or wallpaper first. The ideas about dividing a project into “expensive” and “not expensive” is valid, but ugly color on an expensive backsplash is something you’ll hate every time you see it. Find a fabric that has the color and harmony you are looking for, pull the colors from that. Do some of the cheap colors first, make sure you like it. Best of luck!

    1. pam kueber says:

      Yes, I also agree with finding inspiration pieces — like a piece of fabric or wallpaper to help guide palette decisions!

  3. Stacy says:

    I’m glad to see my fellow Alabamian found some metal cabinets- please don’t tell me you had to drive hundreds of miles to get them! I, too, love color and it really got me in some trouble at our last home. It was just too much and I tried hard to like it, I didn’t. And, it became hard to coordinate other colors. We moved last year to our 1920s home and fearful I might make the same mistakes again (no more hot pink kitchens!) I confess, I paid a decorator to help me choose my paint colors. And I still have color, but it looks right this time.

    1. Ashley says:

      Stacy! I did not have to drive 100s of miles to my surprise! It did take me about a year to find the cabinets but I found them in Tenn. My first set I found in Nashville and the second in Knoxville! According to both people I bought them from those cabinets were pretty wide spread throughout the areas and both areas where the houses are, are pretty popular right now to purchase homes…so I would keep an eye out for more sets!

  4. Becky says:

    We just did white laminate in “sculpted”. We used it for the back splash as well and I know we will never tire of it, or consider it dated. It could be the calm in your sea of colors. The sculpted texture gives it a cool look without competing with the other elements in the room.

  5. lisa says:

    What about extending the mustard all the way through the living room, and leaving the kitchen colors as-is? I like all your colors but the contrast of the dark jade right next to the orange is too extreme for me. I don’t know what you are doing for countertop, but I vote something to warm the space a bit but not too contrasting. I know you said laminate, but actually wood could be very nice (as Pam suggests).

    Then, in the now-mustard living room, add a rug or throw pillows or other accessories that bring in that jade color. Here is one rug possibility: http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Hand-made-Amber-Green-New-Zealand-Blend-Wool-Rug-5-x-8/6237320/product.html?refccid=X26YMBUNLUG2LOSOC7QGQVHG5E&searchidx=154

  6. Blondie7 says:

    What a lovely and beautiful home Ashley! What a superb décor taste you. I would definitely go with Pam’s “warm it up” retro kitchen picture and paint those lovely cabinets white, to make the green Big Chill refrigerator pop. What a gorgeous home!

  7. char says:

    you’re redoing the mint green kitchen cabinets? i wouldn’t – i’d leave the kitchen alone – it’s fabulous just repaint the orange wall and built ins to match the couch, or change the color of all 3

  8. char says:

    okay….the couch, the other wall and the shelves need to be the same color – since the colors in the kitchen are so cohesive and work so well, the same theory needs to apply in the living room – my 2 cents which is worth 2 cents!!!!!!!!

  9. char says:

    Wait! The orange of the shelves does not match the orange of the couch. Put them right next to each other. An easy way to pull the color in would be to make throw pillows – but these need to be closer to the same color I think! Looking again, that orange/yellow wall is a third kind of orange still….they all need to be COHESIVE! Cohesive is good. I wouldn’t touch the kitchen tho. Maybe a mint green floormat is it. And I love the pink Fiestaware pitcher but it clashes. Pink clashes w/ orange unless of course you want it to and like it!!!!

Comments are closed.