model houseWhen I am interviewed for stories involving mid-century houses, reporters almost always ask, “Why do you and your readers love mid-century houses so much… What is the appeal?” In today’s sound-bite age, the pressure is on for a snappy answer. But for me, the reasons I have grown to love mid-century houses are multifaceted. Golly six years into the blog, and it’s only now I am writing this down? Here goes — 12 reasons to own and love a mid-century house, based on my experience including interacting with thousands of readers. In a kinda sorta order:

1. Mid-century houses often were built in locations that today, are desirable:

Location — I am very conservative about big-money purchases. I am a believer in the classic real estate maxim that the three most important factors to consider when buying a house are, yes: Location, location, location. Fortunately, in many cases, mid-century houses are in good locations. They can be in mature, well-tended neighborhoods with wonderful character, caring neighbors and friendly-sized neighborhood shopping areas nearby. In addition, American suburbs often were developed, over time, in proceeding concentric rings around towns and cities. This means the mid-century neighborhoods can be relatively close to town and city centers, making them easy to commute from; they are not typically remote “exurbs.”

2. Mid-century homes often were built with outstanding quality materials and workmanship that have, and will continue to endure:

dutch boy paintGood quality workmanship —  Golly, many of these houses were well made. Mud-set tile… Steel kitchen cabinets… Gorgeous vintage lighting… lovely paneling… and more, in many houses. Yes, there may be some refreshing needed. There may be hazards such as lead and asbestos etc. and other not-to-today’s-code issues that you need to get educated on and invest in handling appropriately; consult with your own properly licensed professionals, for more info see our Be Safe / Renovate Safe page. And, there can be ugly surprise maintenance costs. But my sense is that new construction can have its own problems and even nightmares… and that in general, wonderfully crafted mid-century houses still exist by the hundreds of thousands — even by the millions.

3. Mid-century houses — and especially, mid-century modest houses — can be found at relatively affordable prices:

Check out our story, 46 years of Aladdin Home Catalogs

Price — Mid-century homes tend to be smaller than new construction. This is the first reason they may cost less than new or more recent constructed houses, which today average much larger than 50 years ago. In addition, the finishes used inside mid-century homes were typically not what the mainstream market today would consider high-end — no granite or marble or the like. That may put the brakes on their current sales price. And, because original features may read as “dated” to many buyers, the relative purchase price may be better, compared to new construction or to homes that have been “updated” <- now, there’s a word we are wary of here. Finally, even an old house that’s a “fixer upper” in need of repairs is more attractive to me and Kate — we don’t want to pay for someone else’s recent “upgrades” that we don’t like. We would rather get the house at a discounted price and take the chance that we can do the remodeling on budget in way more pleasing to our period tastes. All of these issues suggest you might be able to ‘get in cheaper’ versus buying a newer house.

Of course the overall “better pricing” equation may not be true depending on the market you’re in — in many hip-to-the-vibe locations now, mid-century houses with their original features intact have become more desirable, with the trendiest architectural examples selling quickly.

4. Small mid-century houses can cost less to maintain and remodel:

The new pink bathroom tile that Kate used in her bathroom remodel was under $5 per s.f. Read all the stories about Kate’s epic bathroom project here. 

Size and unpretentiousness = Long term affordability — In addition to costing less because it’s small, a smallish mid-century house will likely scale to require fewer expenditures happily ever after. Small can mean: (1) Less house to pay to maintain, (2) Less house to heat and air condition, (3) Less house to furnish, (4) Less house to pay taxes and insurance on, (5) Less house to clean. Kate adds that a ranch style house means (6) Easier to DIY roof repair$ and hou$e painting and $uch. All of this, by the way, means the less you will need to work to pay for it all. Also, the fact that the authentic period finishes on these house are not ‘fancy’ by today’s standards, means that materials required for restoration may be less costly. For mid-century houses we are talking: 4″ bathroom tiles… resilient flooring… plain cabinets… simple sinks and tubs… and many of these items can be purchased vintage, at ReStores and the like, for rock bottom prices. Peoples, I am telling you:  Turn away from the siren song of keeping up with the Joneses and the everlasting gobstopper American marketing machine that works ceaselessly to burrow new-new-new-buy-buy-buy messages into our brains… keep the finishes in your mid-century house simple, which is architecturally appropriate anyway, and squirrel “the savings” into your retirement.

5. Old is the new Green:

brown vintage stove in dumpsterEmbodied energy — These houses already exist. Buy one — and as possible, practical and advisable, retain its original features — and you likely will be helping to avoid additional energy and natural resource use versus building or buying new. Of course, when it comes to energy and environmental features of our houses, each one will need to be assessed on its own; that said, I continue to find it impossible to mentally process the suggestion that we can consume our way out of a consumption process — that is: the implication of “build a green house!” and “buy this green product!” stories that imply that by abandoning our old housing stock in favor of building all-new “energy efficient” housing structures — or, by gutting existing houses and replacing still-functional stuff inside — we would be setting ourselves up for a better environmental future. I flat out find this impossible to believe; I need to see the calculus of how much carbon, water, forest, etc. this massive reworking of our housing stock would chew up.Waste distresses me, so I intensely favor buying existing houses: Use it up, wear it out, make it do. Note: At the end of January 2014, there were 1.9 million existing-built homes for sale in the U.S., the National Association of Realtors reported. The NAR considers this a 4.9-month supply, at the existing sales rate (which was slow in January), under the approximately six-month supply generally recommended. That said, there are now 10,000 Baby Boomers turning 65 daily. Additional houses will be heading our way soon enough….

6. Mid-century was a heyday of architectural inventiveness:

If you are really really really lucky, you’ll score a time capsule house with its own bowling alley in the basement.

Great architecture and features — Mid-century America was a period of immense innovation. Merchant builders built houses that were stylin’. My sense is that there were lots more major manufacturers in the marketplace supplying products, so there was a lot of competition, which meant a lot of proud invention — amazing stoves! sparkle laminate! cork floors! amazing tile! Homeowners did wicked awesome things like build tiki bars in their basements. And again, quality of workmanship was often wonderful. All this adds up to discovering many wonderful features in mid-century houses. There was interesting design, outside and in.

Another thing we Retro Renovators have in common, I’ve typically found, is that we are highly visual. Once we own or live in a mid-century home, we can easily become fascinated by the aesthetics of the period. That said: All design is highly visual, so I think you could be a highly visual person and be into any interior design style. But I think that our highly visual nature, combined with all the other factors on this list, make the mid-century period a particularly appealing one for us.

7. As cozy as Grandma’s kitchen, hey it is grandma’s kitchen:

1946 Merillat kitchen that was built by the company’s owner and his wife, by hand, for one of their first employees. Now in the company archives.

Warm fuzzies — Our definition of mid-century houses includes both “mid-century modern” and “mid-century modest.” Interestingly, while “moderns” and “modests” may have been designed to look very different on the outside, on the inside they often shared many many design features — namely, use of unpretentious materials, interesting design features, and similar pastel bathrooms and colorful kitchens. Mid-century modern houses: Hard not to get gaga over the fabulous lines of these houses. Add color, and they are so fun.  Mid-century modest houses: These can be so00000 cozy. The ceilings are not super high. The homes envelop us.

America is such a mobile country — so many of us needed to move for jobs — our roots may be far away. We love our mobility, but hey, we miss our kinfolk, too… and the cozy features within our mid-century houses remind us of our Grandma’s house. My grandma had a kitchen full of knotty pine galore, a den with a wall full of family photos, and bathrooms with sunny tile. Happy happy memories, easy to channel if you own a mid-century house. 

8. All the modern amenities:

youngstown-catalog-sm-after“Modern” living — My sense is that for the mass of America prior to World War II, it was a hard-knock life. But the economy boomed after World War II. And houses from that point on began bringing all kinds of “modern” amenities to the largest generation of families ever… Modern conveniences like: electricity, indoor bathroom plumbing, central heating [and with it, larger windows], “fitted kitchens”, larger flowing rooms, and more. Today, all these same features continue to comprise the fundamental requirements for contemporary homes. Not a lot has really changed. Today, homes need better amperage… windows are double-paned (although not likely made better)… the materials we use to build homes or fit them out may differ… ya got yer low-flow toilets and Energy Star appliances (again, likely not made with as much quality as back in the day)… and certainly many superficial “fashion” choices may be different. But even if you live in a mid-century house that is 50 years old, you are likely living in a house that still is almost entirely suitable to contemporary 21st century living.

Hey: Because a mid-century house may be smaller and cost less to purchase and maintain, it may be MORE suited to 21st century living, if you are concerned about climate change and having the money — in a less stable economic and jobs environment — to maintain it and even to hold on to it.

9. Great for aging in place:

Read this story from 2009 — I explored whether, s.f. per s.f., was this the best ranch house plan yet.

Floor plan: Mid-century houses often were ranch-style houses or Cape Cods with bedrooms on the ground level. Single-story ranch houses, in particular, are great for aging in place. Having lived in several styles of homes, I would go a step beyond and say that ranches — with those bedrooms close at hand and nice circulation and flow — are more livable for virtually anyone and everyone — although I do miss all the exercise I got going up and down stairs 800 times a day when I lived in two-story houses. Sort of. Note, I do acknowledge: Ranch style houses require larger lots – and obviously, the larger and more sprawling the home is, the more land will be required; my understanding is that building up, if you need space, is more economical along a number of dimensions.

10. Getting trendier every day:

midcentury-modern-houston-sputnik-house-1957-7 (2)
Heck to the yeah to the Sputnik house!

They’re hip(ish) — When I started this blog in 2007, there already was a market for mid-century modern houses — the architect-designed confections, with impractical roof lines, especially on the West Coast. In the six+ years since, interest in these mid-century modern houses has really exploded. Meanwhile, flash back to 2007 and mid-century modest houses were not much on the fashcionista radar, they were disparaged, even. But then came Mad Men (Betty had a knotty pine kitchen) … and in general, 50 years passed and there was a new generation of buyers without any baggage…. and all the kids are wearing retro anyway… and more Baby Boomers were retiring, and they were nostalgic and downsizing and wanting ranch houses… and there was a Great Recession, and small, affordable houses were sort of appealing again… and I’ll even suggest there was the internet, including this blog, connecting folks to mid-mod alternatives and resources… and before you knew it, the world began to see the charm of the simple tract house. Today, there’s much more interest in mid-century houses — modern and modest alike — with lots of readers telling me that they are searching for old houses from the era to call their own.

11. Multi-generational neighborhoods:

anne taintor
Anne Taintor January 2014 caption contest winner Robert Wooldridge.

Neighbors from the way-back days — Live in a mid-century neighborhood, and chances are there are original owners in their original houses nearby. Theirs may be the last generation in America not to move nine times (or whatever) because of job changes. It’s so nice to have some grandma and grandpa-aged neighbors around, to tell us what the place looked like from the start, don’t you think?

12: Wonderful stories, and Polaroids, too:

Remember Gabe & Amanda’s stunning mid-century modern house? Sons (above) of the original owners came to visit and share stories about their childhood home.
Leota & Tobias Schindler, original owners of this lovely house
Leota & Tobias Schindler, original owners of this lovely house

The stories — This one is related to #11 … and is one of my favorite “unexpected surprises” about the joy of owning a mid-century house: There are folks still around who can tell us first-hand stories about our homes, including who built them, who lived there and why. I am sure there are wonderful stories about Victorian and Arts ‘n Crafts houses, etc., too. But we can longer hear those stories first-hand, and there likely aren’t many photos. Readers with mid-century houses, on the other hand, report experience after experience of meeting the original owners, or their children, of their houses. The original owners share information and stories and photos and architectural drawings…. In my house, the grown child of early, longtime owners showed me where he stashed his teenaged Marlboros (they are still in their hiding place; he searched; yes, they were there, and then we put them back – a little time capsule.) He showed me where his beloved boyhood dog chewed the door molding at the top of the basement stairs — and I now treasure that boo boo. He showed me where the dog was buried in the backyard. His mother sent me photos taken in the house in the 1950s — weddings, Christmas, the original kitchen…. It’s all so heartwarming, I could bust. I am just the latest caretaker of this treasure of a house. Which there are oh-so many reasons to love.

What do you think, dear readers: Did I capture the big reasons we love our mid-century houses?

And for sure: I would love to hear — in great detail — yes! — the exact reasons that you chose your home!

Tip: If you do want to write a long answer, write it out in Word first, then cut and paste it into a Comment. In case something goes wrong, I don’t want you to lose your thoughtful work!

  1. Donna Stephens says:

    Pam I loved this post. I have a mid century modest home that I fell in love with when I walked in and saw the stone fireplace! Although, I have changed some small things around the house, it is pretty much as is. Most people who see it love the coziness and comfort of my home. I agree that doing “remodeling” is less expensive in modest homes especially if you replacing with materials that they may of used back in the day such as laminate vs granite etc…or as you say loving the house you are in-somethings just don’t need to be redone/updated just because it isn’t in “style”.

  2. Scott says:

    I think the only thing I can add to the many wise comments above is that when you buy a Modern or Modest House in an existing neighborhood you know what you are getting. The way your street looks now is the way it looked 10 years ago. And ten years from now it will probably have changed very little. More importantly the same goes for the vibe of the neighborhood. I like the way it feels to live here. It feels like home, not a trophy that will tide me over until I can get something even bigger and better.

  3. Katie says:

    Another reason to love older houses: NO HoAs. I like not having to pay for the “privilege” of being told what I can and cannot do with my property. In my neighborhood, people keep their houses looking nice because we have pride in our homes, not because we’re afraid of some busybody fining us. I know of HoAs in this area where residents can only have a dog below 25 pounds (and the scale gets whipped out if Fido is looking a bit portly), vegetables cannot be grown in the front yard, trees cannot be over a certain height or girth (so forget about mature trees shading your home), houses must be painted one of three approved shades of beige, garage doors cannot be left open more than ten minutes….
    I think I’ll stick with my mid-century modest neighborhood.

  4. Kelly says:

    Our house is listed as constructed in 1948, but was actually built during the war as federal housing for workers building Liberty Ships and moved to our lovely, recently-recognized-as-historic neighborhood that year. Most of the houses in our neighborhood are from the 50s and 60s. We just closed a week and a half ago. We’re primarily living in the front part of the house, which has the original hardwood floors and textured sheetrock ceilings. The 1970 addition with it’s fake wood paneling, disgusting ceiling tiles, and yucky carpet over plywood, is mostly storage while we save up the money to get it to match the front. We’re exhausted from all the hard work, but the look of these red oak floors, now that they’ve been liberated from their 1980s carpet prison, makes it all worth it!

  5. Lauryn says:

    I love this post! Our 1939 house is a little older than what would be considered mid-century (and this blog occasionally gets me drooling about owning a 50s or 60s ranch like the to-die-for Sputnik House) but so many of your points applied to us when we bought this house. It was cozy, well-built and maintained, had oak floors throughout and sweet little architectural touches, like archways and built-ins; it was small enough to not cost a fortune to maintain, heat, and cool; it is in a great neighborhood, very affordable with reasonable taxes, and I just fell in love with its charm. Everything about it suited us. And while I like to believe we will be able to climb the stairs to the “half-story” upstairs well into our 90s, everything really is suited to one-story living (bedrooms and full bath all on the first floor).

    I love this blog, love how enthusiastic people are about preserving this wonderful part of our country’s history. This particular post really sums up so much of what it is all about for lovers of this era!

    Oh, and when we were getting bids for painting, someone asked if we planned on still being here in 5 years. He was so surprised when we said yes, but we’re taking a cue from the original owner (we’re #4), who lived here 47 years!

  6. Sharon Mullican says:

    This is a wonderful website. I love my 1955 house…sadly I had to remove the kitchen tile and cabinets and replaced the non-repairable, non-functional windows with ones with a similar appearance and doublepane glass. A previous owner had decided to reface the orginal painted, built on-site kitchen cabinets. In the process they damaged the doors and frames making it impossible to repair the doors and drawer fronts that kept falling off. But I’m keeping my pink bathroom and aqua 3/4 bathroom! You make wonderful points about the value of older neighborhoods. It makes environmental sense and I’m located near everything, the house is one level and not overly large..and it’s in a real neighborhood without an HOA.

  7. RD says:

    This website has helped me tremendously to appreciate what I have in my 1952 ranch house. Solid construction, thick wood trim, maple floors throughout, pocket doors in the kitchen and living room, etc. I had originally thought we would need to replace our windows but a window-guy came out to our house and said that our windows were “top of the line” back when they were installed. Then he said it would cost $21k to replace about half of them with the same quality of wood trim. So, I’m now just trying to make them more efficient (caulking, weatherstripping, etc.) and have completely abandoned the idea of replacing them.

    Having a one story ranch really came in handy this summer when we needed to paint our house. My husband and I painted the whole thing ourselves and we only paid for paint and supplies. Our neighbors had professionals paint their house and it cost them $5000 to paint their small one-story ranch. We sure do feel good about the money we saved by doing it ourselves.

    At one point, I wanted to buy a really old house, say from the 1800s or thereabouts. A few within our price range were on the market when we were looking. I love their character but when I thought about owning a house like that, I was extremely nervous about the amount of money needed to maintain it. What if the roof goes? What if the siding needs painting or replacing? I doubt anything could be done for less than $10,000 (everything’s expensive here). When we found our little ranch, the inspector said, “This house is solid. It was built RIGHT.” That sure is a great comfort for me.

    Plus, I have come to appreciate the character of mid-century houses, even the mid-century “modest” ones like mine.

    One other thing that I like about living in a modest house is that it allows me to “walk the talk” in front of my children when I try to teach them the values of modesty, living within your means, and staying true to yourself and not trying to keep up with the Joneses.

    1. pam kueber says:

      You are very lucky you had a window person who wasn’t just trying to sell you new windows at whatever the waste! Also, I love what you say about walking the talk in front of your children. Role modeling is everything, preaching is virtually nothing.

    2. Jacki says:

      We have had both the 1903 Victorian and the Mid Century Ranch. We owned the Queen Anne in OK and while it was a traffic stopper (literally had folks stop to photograph it) it was a serious money pit and we spent all of our spare time and money working on it. Our MC ranch is in AZ and while it needed work and money and still does, It is so much more affordable and easier to work on than the QA. Plus, the time involved in the tedious dusting of all that woodwork! Love my MCR more.

    3. Joe Felice says:

      People used to keep their original wood windows. Am I the only one who remembers storm windows? This is what we installed on the outside of our wonderful wood windows to provide energy efficiency. this was popular until the mid ’80s, when people started ripping out their original windows and installing double-paned ones. I had Sears put storm windows on my 1952 ranch for $300.00, which I though was a lot at the time. Then I had to unseal the wood windows, which the previous owners had painted shut. There wasn’t a window in that house that could be opened prior to that!

  8. Brian says:

    My home was built in 1971 with many mid century nods in design. It is built of brick and stone. The materials are solid. I’m not worried about it going anywhere.

  9. Gabrielle says:

    I wouldn’t be surprised if I did. I love the fun colors they used back then. I love the old turqoise bathroom tiles. And I also love the bright colors they made steel cabinets in. I already dig through thrift shops, estate sales, and yard sales looking for cool retro decor, clothing, and vinyl. All my furniture is 1970′s era or older. I can’t remember the last time I bought a brand new lamp or clock, I bought vintage ones.

  10. Sara of WA says:

    As a Realtor I can say that typically the older homes have the bigger lots. So families can have a real back yard rather than a strip of grass to mow. So much healthier for everybody from growing a garden and having a play structure to the health benefits of gardening.

Comments are closed.